“An account is already registered with your email address” in WooCommerce: why checkout tries to create an account
WooCommerce shows this when the checkout tries to create a new account for an email address that already has one. Here is when the checkout creates accounts, and how to let returning customers through.
In this article13 sections
This notice means the checkout tried to create a new customer account, and the email address the shopper entered already belongs to an account. WooCommerce won’t create a second account with the same email, so it stops and asks them to log in.
The question is usually why the checkout was creating an account at all. It does that in two cases only, and both are under your control.
The exact message#
An account is already registered with your email address. Please log in.
The same failure can also read:
- An account is already registered with jane@example.com. Please log in or use a different email address.
- Error: An account is already registered with jane@example.com. Please log in or use a different email address.
Who sees it: Logged-out shoppers, after pressing Place order on the classic checkout. Please log in is a link that opens the login form on the same page. The checkout block shows the second wording, with the email address. The registration form on the My account page shows the same text after “Error:”.
What WooCommerce checks#
When a logged-out shopper places an order, WooCommerce creates an account for them only if:
- Guest checkout is off and account creation during checkout is on, so every logged-out order creates an account (with both off, the checkout asks shoppers to log in instead), or
- the shopper ticked Create an account?, which appears when account creation during checkout is allowed.
Before creating it, WooCommerce checks whether any WordPress user, of any role, already has that email address. If one does, the order stops with this message. Logged-in shoppers never see it, and guests ordering with guest checkout on, without ticking the box, don’t either.
Causes and how to fix each one#
1. Guest checkout is turned off#
With Enable guest checkout unticked and account creation during checkout allowed under WooCommerce > Settings > Accounts & Privacy, every logged-out order creates an account. A returning customer who doesn’t log in first is treated as new, and their own email address blocks them.
Check: Go to WooCommerce > Settings > Accounts & Privacy and look at Checkout: Enable guest checkout.
Fix: Tick Enable guest checkout, or keep it off and tick Enable log-in during checkout so returning customers see a login prompt at the top of the checkout.
2. The shopper ticked Create an account?#
When Account creation: During checkout is on, logged-out shoppers see a Create an account? box. Customers who already have an account but forgot often tick it again.
Check: Ask the customer whether they ticked Create an account?, or try the same email yourself with the box ticked.
Fix: The customer logs in with the link in the message, or unticks the box and orders as a guest.
3. The customer thinks they are logged in but aren’t#
Their login may have expired, or they logged in on a different address of the site, such as www versus non-www, so the checkout sees a logged-out visitor.
Check: Ask the customer whether the checkout showed the Returning customer? login prompt or a Create an account? box; logged-in customers see neither. Test logging in and moving to the checkout yourself.
Fix: Make the site use one address, so a login on one page counts on the checkout too.
4. The email belongs to a non-customer account#
The check covers every WordPress user, not just customers. An administrator, shop manager, author or subscriber with that email address blocks it too. Store owners testing the checkout while logged out with their own email hit this.
Check: Search Users in the WordPress admin for the email address and look at the account’s role.
Fix: Log in to that account before ordering, or use a different email address for test orders.
5. A plugin requires an account#
Plugins can make an account mandatory through the woocommerce_checkout_registration_required filter, for example for products that need ongoing access or billing. Guest checkout then looks on in the settings, but the checkout still creates accounts.
Check: If guest checkout is on and Create an account? isn’t shown, test with other plugins turned off using the Health Check & Troubleshooting plugin.
Fix: Change the plugin’s account settings, or tell customers to log in before buying those products.
Quick reference#
| Cause | How to check | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Guest checkout is turned off | Go to WooCommerce > Settings > Accounts & Privacy and look at Checkout: Enable guest checkout. | Tick Enable guest checkout, or keep it off and tick Enable log-in during checkout so returning customers see a login prompt at the top of the checkout. |
| The shopper ticked Create an account? | Ask the customer whether they ticked Create an account?, or try the same email yourself with the box ticked. | The customer logs in with the link in the message, or unticks the box and orders as a guest. |
| The customer thinks they are logged in but aren't | Ask the customer whether the checkout showed the Returning customer? login prompt or a Create an account? box; logged-in customers see neither. Test logging in and moving to the checkout yourself. | Make the site use one address, so a login on one page counts on the checkout too. |
| The email belongs to a non-customer account | Search Users in the WordPress admin for the email address and look at the account's role. | Log in to that account before ordering, or use a different email address for test orders. |
| A plugin requires an account | If guest checkout is on and Create an account? isn't shown, test with other plugins turned off using the Health Check & Troubleshooting plugin. | Change the plugin's account settings, or tell customers to log in before buying those products. |
Reproduced on a test store#
We set up each case below on a clean WooCommerce 11.2.1 store on 6 November 2026 and recorded exactly what it showed.
| What we did | What WooCommerce showed |
|---|---|
| Settings > Accounts & Privacy: Enable guest checkout unticked; Account creation During checkout ticked. A customer account exists for jane@example.com. Logged out, add a product priced 10, enter jane@example.com as the billing email, place the order. | An account is already registered with your email address. Please log in. |
| Enable guest checkout ticked; Account creation During checkout ticked. Logged out, enter jane@example.com, tick Create an account?, place the order. | An account is already registered with your email address. Please log in. |
| Enable guest checkout ticked. Logged out, enter jane@example.com, leave Create an account? unticked, place the order. | No message. The order was placed. |
| Guest checkout off. Logged out, use the site administrator's email address as the billing email. | An account is already registered with your email address. Please log in. |
| Guest checkout off, Account creation During checkout ticked, Checkout block. Logged out, use jane@example.com. | An account is already registered with jane@example.com. Please log in or use a different email address. |
| Account creation On "My account" page ticked. Logged out, register on the My account page with jane@example.com. | Error: An account is already registered with jane@example.com. Please log in or use a different email address. |
For developers#
The classic checkout’s text can be changed with woocommerce_registration_error_email_exists, which receives the message and the email address:
add_filter( 'woocommerce_registration_error_email_exists', function ( $message, $email ) {
return 'You already have an account with us. Please log in above to complete your order.';
}, 10, 2 );Whether an account is required is woocommerce_checkout_registration_required; whether customers may create one at checkout is woocommerce_checkout_registration_enabled.
Where this lives in WooCommerce 11.2.1:
includes/class-wc-checkout.php,WC_Checkout::process_customer: Creates an account when the shopper is logged out and registration is required or Create an account was ticked; replaces the email-exists error with this message (filter woocommerce_registration_error_email_exists).includes/class-wc-checkout.php,WC_Checkout::is_registration_required: Registration is required whenever woocommerce_enable_guest_checkout isn’t yes; filter woocommerce_checkout_registration_required.includes/wc-user-functions.php,wc_create_new_customer: Returns the email-exists error when email_exists() finds any WordPress user with that address.src/StoreApi/Routes/V1/Checkout.php,Checkout::process_customer: The block checkout passes the email-exists error through with its own wording.templates/checkout/form-login.php,checkout/form-login.php template: The hidden login form that the Please log in link opens.includes/admin/settings/class-wc-settings-accounts.php,WC_Settings_Accounts::get_settings_for_default_section: Labels for Enable guest checkout, Enable log-in during checkout and the Account creation options.
Related WooCommerce errors#
- Sorry, your session has expired. Return to shop
- We were unable to process your order, please try again.
- Invalid payment method.
Back to the WooCommerce error reference.
Frequently asked questions#
Can a customer order with an email that already has an account without logging in?
Yes, when guest checkout is on and they don’t tick Create an account?. The order is then placed as a guest order.
Why does the Please log in link do nothing?
It opens the login form at the top of the checkout. If a theme or plugin removed that form, the link has nothing to open. Customers can still log in from My account.
Was the order placed?
No. On the classic checkout the account check runs before the order is created. The checkout block already has a draft order at that point, but it is never placed.
Why does the checkout block word it differently?
The block checkout shows the message from the account-creation code itself, which names the email address and suggests using a different one.
I deleted the customer but the email is still taken. Why?
Check Users for another account with the same email, such as a subscriber or an admin. Any WordPress user counts.